
Cortland Man Arrested After Domestic Incident, Allegedly Punches Officer
A Cortland man is facing multiple charges after a domestic incident Monday afternoon led to a brief struggle with Cortland Police, during which police say he struck an officer in the face.
Police were dispatched to 51 Port Watson Street around 1:30 p.m. Monday, August 31, for a reported disturbance. Officers later determined the incident involved a domestic dispute.
Upon arrival, officers located 33-year-old James A. Gay of Cortland in the building’s lobby. Police learned Gay had been involved in an argument with a family member.
According to police, further investigation determined that during the argument, Gay allegedly yelled at the victim and threw a backpack at her, striking her right arm. Police also say Gay threw a coffee cup toward the victim, although it did not strike her.
Police said a non-harassment order of protection was already in place at the time of the incident.
The victim told officers she feared for her safety and attempted to call 911, but police say Gay took her phone. The victim then fled her apartment and sought assistance from a neighboring apartment, where law enforcement was contacted.
Cortland Police said the victim did not have any visible injuries and declined medical treatment.
As officers continued their investigation, they advised Gay that he was under arrest. Police say Gay refused multiple commands and became physically resistant when officers attempted to take him into custody.
During the arrest, police say Gay swung a closed fist at an officer, striking the officer in the face. Officers were able to restrain Gay and place him in handcuffs. The officer was not injured.
Gay was transported to the police station for processing. He faces multiple charges, including two counts of second-degree harassment, fourth-degree criminal mischief, resisting arrest, aggravated family offense, first-degree criminal contempt, second-degree menacing, and third-degree criminal possession of a weapon.
Gay was processed and later arraigned. He was remanded to the Cortland County Jail and is expected to appear in City Court next week.
Cortland Police said a stay-away order of protection was requested following the incident.



